YOU ARE HERE: HOMESCHOOLING > THOUGHTS & OPINIONS > CONTROVERSY

A to Z Home's Cool Home Page


Homeschooling books and supplies at discount, no sales tax, and free shipping!

A to Z Home's Cool Homeschooling

Photo of Ann Zeise, homeschooling guide  

Thoughts & Hard Facts

I am Ann Zeise, your guide to the best and most interesting and useful sites and articles about home education on the web.

Homeschooling ~ Recent Articles ~ A2Z Groups ~ A2Z Blogs ~ Contact Ann Zeise ~ Curriculum Shopping
Site Index: A  B  C  D  E  F  G  H  I  J  K  L  M  N  O  P  Q  R  S  T  U  V  W  X  Y  Z

Controversy

Compulsory Education
Curfews
Forced Homeschooling
HR 2732
National Politics
We Stand For Homeschooling
Other Controversial Issues

Thoughts & Opinions

Accreditation

Controversy
Demographics
Dispelling the Stereotype
Education Reform
HeartMath
Homeschooling Is Best
HSLDA Consumer Info
John Taylor Gatto
News About Homeschooling
Public Homeschool Programs
Numbers of Homeschoolers
Ravage of Home Education
Research
Resources
School Issues
Socialization: The "S" Word
Taking Charge
Testing Homeschoolers
 
Christian
 
Christian Homeschooling
Classical Christian Education
Controversy
HSLDA and HSLDA/F
Ravage of Home Education
Religious Distance Learning
Religious Unschooling
 
Christian Curriculum
 
Alpha Omega Academy
Alpha Omega Publications
Christian Materials
Christian Unit Studies
Sonlight

A to Z Home's Cool

Welcome to Homeschooling
Articles
Beginning to Homeschool
Chat Room
Community Networking
Concerns
Curriculum Shopping
Distance Learning Programs
DVD Rentals
Early Years
Events
Explorations 4 Kids
Field Trips
Gifted Kids
Holiday Directory
Homeschooling Jokes
Laws & Legalities
Lessons & Ideas
Methods, Styles
Regional Information
Religion & Cultural
Special Needs
Support Group Resources
Teens & College-Bound
Thoughts & Hard Facts
Unschooling

Controversy

Sponsored Links

Homeschool NonDiscrimination Act of 2005

"While the intent of the bill may be honorable, the effect of the bill is potentially disastrous for homeschooling parents who want to remain free from government regulation. This is because the federal government has no constitutional authority to directly regulate the education of homeschooled students, whether that regulation is for the benefit of the students or not."

I'm not sure who wrote the above quote, but I sure agree with it!

HR 2732 - Home School Non-Discrimination Act of 2003

Bill Number Search
Enter HR 2732 in "Bill Number" search field.

The Camel's Nose Enters the Homeschooling Tent
One sound argument for deregulation, that homeschoolers ask for no special privileges and no tax dollars and thus should be left alone, is lost if this amendment passes. Ann Lahrson-Fisher.

Eligibility of Home-Schooled Students Institutional and Student Eligibility
Also known as the "Dear Colleague" Letter. How come HSLDA is asking for changes in the Higher Education Act if they already say the problem has been resolved?

Federal homeschool legislation???
Once the federal government assumes the authority to regulate, even though purportedly beneficially, the federal government may continue to regulate in ways that may not be beneficial. Little Bit Farm.

HSLDA Supports HR 2732
Homeschoolers do not want federal handouts, just equal treatment. HONDA will bring federal law up-to-date with changes in the state education systems, particularly regarding the homeschooling movement.

Petition: Protect your educational rights! Say no to HR 2732!
Sign this petition and let our government know that we will not accept bill HR 2732.

Saving For College - Coverdell ESA
There are no restrictions about the current education status of a child for setting up one of these college saving accounts. Any family below a specified income level may set one up. So there is no need to concern yourselves. You can set one up without HR 2732 passing.

Say No To The Federal Homeschool Legislation
HSLDA is presenting incorrect, misleading, and exaggerated claims for what the bill would accomplish. Even in the unlikely event that the bill brought a few small gains for homeschoolers, those gains would not be worth the risks of opening the door to federal regulation of homeschooling, creating a backlash against homeschoolers, and strengthening the power of the federal government. Larry and Susan Kaseman, Home Education Magazine

We Stand For Homeschooling

We Stand For Homeschooling
Original Document: The very nature, language and essence of homeschooling are being challenged and even co-opted by a vast array of emerging educational programs which may be based in the home, but are funded by government tax dollars, bringing inevitable government controls.

HEM's Intro to We Stand For Homeschooling
Our fervent hope is that we won't be remembered as those who clumsily dropped the ball and let the promising potential of homeschooling in freedom and independence be lost. Mark and Helen Hegener, Home Education Magazine.

Why I Will Not Sign the "We Stand for Homeschooling Statement and Resolution"
My first objection is that, to be perfectly truthful, I've never been a homeschooling parent myself, and my children have never been homeschoolers. You see, I live in California. According to the California Education Code, there are no such people as homeschoolers. Mary Griffith, Unschooler and Author.

Is Charter Schooling Really Homeschooling?
I think it's curious that when those of us (independent homeschoolers) who try to gently voice our growing uneasiness over the charter school epidemic within the homeschool community, we are immediately labeled anti-charter, no matter how valid our concern. By Annette M. Hall.

Compulsory Education

Colonial Education
See a real Hornbook and New England Primer. See a view of the Dame School. Link into even more information about early schools, educational material, and laws.

Curfews

Being a Kid is Not a Crime A GO MILPITAS! ARTICLE
Thoughts on curfews and links to web sites with curfew law information.

Curfews and Homeschoolers
Daytime curfews require that police stop and question young people who appear to be of school age but are not in a school building during conventional school hours. Those who cannot provide a convincing reason for not being in school are either fined or taken into custody.

Nighttime Curfews or You Wanna Do What to my Kid?
Mary McCarthy tells how she researched and fought a proposed curfew in her Borough in New York. She recommends searching the ACLU site for help wording arguments. [HEM]

Truancy, Curfews and Our Response
Janie Levine Hellyer asked families to tell us what they were seeing and how the new regulations were affecting their families and communities. [HEM]

Forced Homeschooling by the Reconstructionist Movement

Exodus 2000 Project
This is a project undertaken to remove children from the public education system which has failed, and is believed to be getting worse, and put them into private Christian schools and Home Schools.

"Let My Children Go": A Christian Exodus from Government Schools?
E. Ray Moore founded and developed the Exodus Mandate Project (formerly known as Exodus 2000) under the auspices of his Frontline Ministries based in the Columbia, South Carolina area.

Reading, Writing & Reconstructionism
The Christian Right and the Politics of Public Education. Note the paragraph about Chris Klicka, one of the HSLDA principles. By Maureen W. McClure, Associate Professor, Administrative and Policy Studies, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA, US.

Reconstruction Theology and Home Education
Mary McCarthy explains how the Christian Reconstructionist movement is using and abusing the homeschool movement to further their ends.

National Politics

Battling for the heart and soul of home-schoolers
Conservative fundamentalists have set the agenda for kids taught at home -- now they're aiming to influence public education. By Helen Cordes, Salon, October 2, 2000.

Democratic Party on Education
Democrats know that the key to expanding opportunity is to provide every child with a world-class education. We want to meet our responsibilities to America's children by ensuring that our schools have the resources they need to help our kids meet high standards.

Organize This!
Llewellyn H. Rockwell, Jr.: As the Microsoft case shows, too much success can invite retaliation from the DC forces of destruction. So it was probably inevitable that the Clinton administration would target homeschoolers and put them in their place. (See NEWS for news coverage.)

Remember Your Promise
A humorous tale by Linda Dobson and her Big Chance to talk to the Clintons. HEM Nov/Dec00.

Why do moderate homeschool voices seem to be missing from the national conversation?
I wish there was a greater range of 'homeschooling voices' being heard by the workers in the public information media. By Valerie Bonham Moon.

Other Controversial Issues

Home schoolers ask government to stay out
Home schoolers urged a legislative committee to leave parents alone to teach their children at home, as "a viable and flourishing" alternative to public education.

Is Homeschooling Sexist?
For some families, the issue of women's roles is a nagging question. Laurae Lyster-Mensh, HEM N/D 2000.

The Legality of Private-School Homeschooling in California
Stephan Greenberg, a California lawyer and homeschooling dad, wrote this essay about the right to homeschool from a Constitutional point of view.

Should home-schooled children be welcomed in public-school sports?
The shift came after the Tennessee Secondary School Athletic Association took an unprecedented step in December, when it voted to establish a set of minimum eligibility requirements for home-schooled students to participate in public or private school extracurricular sports.

Vouchers and Educational Freedom: A Debate
Joseph L. Bast and David Harmer versus Douglas Dewey: Would vouchers lead to more freedom or trap private schools in more governmental red tape?

Home Education Magazine Current Issue
Home Education Magazine
Every issue of this award-winning magazine features outstanding articles on a variety of subjects, interesting and informative columns by experienced homeschoolers, and reviews of the best new homeschooling resources. An excellent source of support and encouragement for homeschooling! Subscription Form.
 
Kingdom of Children: Culture and Controversy in the Homeschooling Movement
Kingdom of Children: Culture and Controversy in the Homeschooling Movement
by Mitchell L. Stevens
Moving from why parents opt for home-schooling to the long-term effects on their children, he draws on interviews with a mix of parents from fundamentalist Christians to pagans and educational radicals and persuasively contextualizes the movement within the "organizational strategies of the progressive left and the religious right" in their attempt to preserve their core set of values: "the sanctity of childhood and the primacy of family in the face of an increasingly competitive and bureaucratized society." 15 pages of exerpts available.


The Schools Our Children Deserve

Moving Beyond Traditional Classrooms and "Tougher Standards"
by Kohn, Alfie
Teacher-turned-writer Alfie Kohn takes on traditional-education giants like E.D. Hirsch, along with practically every state government "raising the bar" and toughening standards, in this attack on the back-to-basics movement. 1999 Hardcover

Stealing Jesus : How Fundamentalism Betrays Christianity
Stealing Jesus : How Fundamentalism Betrays Christianity
by Bruce Bawer
In page after page, Bawer reveals a so-called Fundamentalist movement that readily displays a blatant disregard for the most salient message of the Gospels: selfless love and service to all.


Left Back : A Century of Failed School Reforms
by Ravitch, Diane Ravitch
"Whenever the academic curriculum was diluted or minimized, large numbers of children were pushed through the school system without benefit of a genuine education," she writes. 2001 Paperback

Top 10 and Recently Published
Homeschooling Books
SEARCH AGAIN

Welcome to
Homeschooling

Thoughts
& Hard Facts

Curriculum Shopping

Contact
Ann Zeise

© 1997 - Ann Zeise. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Use & Privacy Policy

Advertise